
The Eliza Jane
Best for being steps from the French Quarter, the CBD and convention center, with a strong wedding/event setup.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
The Eliza Jane is a four-star boutique hotel set inside transformed 19th-century warehouse buildings near the French Quarter; read this if you want a historic, centrally located base for sightseeing and events. Hotel Saint Vincent is a stylish 4.5-star boutique luxury hotel on Magazine Street in the Lower Garden District; read this if you prefer Magazine Street shopping, an on-site pool and spa, and a quieter neighborhood feel.
Updated · about 1.2 km apart

Best for being steps from the French Quarter, the CBD and convention center, with a strong wedding/event setup.

Best for boutique luxury in the Lower Garden District with an outdoor pool, on-site spa services, and easy access to Magazine Street.
When The Eliza Jane wins: Choose The Eliza Jane if you want a central, historic downtown address a few blocks from the French Quarter and convention venues, easy access on foot to Canal Street and the Aquarium, a signature French-Louisiana restaurant (Couvant), and flexible event spaces for weddings or meetings.
When Hotel Saint Vincent wins: Choose Hotel Saint Vincent if you prefer a Lower Garden District stay near Magazine Street shopping, want an on-site outdoor pool and spa/massage services, and value extra accessible features and complimentary self parking.
Bottom line: Both are stylish boutique options in New Orleans; pick The Eliza Jane for proximity to the French Quarter, historic character, and event-friendly spaces, or Hotel Saint Vincent for a quieter Magazine Street neighborhood, pool and spa facilities, and a slightly more residential boutique-luxury feel.
| Category | The Eliza Jane | Hotel Saint Vincent |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Historic warehouse conversion, lively downtown energy | Stylish boutique luxury with a residential Lower Garden District feel |
| Location | 315 Magazine St — Central Business District, a few blocks from the French Quarter | 1507 Magazine St — Lower Garden District, steps from Magazine Street |
| Size (rooms) | 196 guestrooms and suites | 75 rooms |
| Property age / setting | Set in transformed 19th-century warehouse buildings | Not published |
| Pools | No on-site pool or hot tub | One outdoor pool (pool access ramp and pool hoist on site) |
| Restaurants & bars | Couvant (French-Louisiana brasserie) and The Press Room lobby bar | San Lorenzo (Mediterranean) plus a coffee shop/cafe and 2 bars/lounges |
| Spa / wellness | No on-site spa services (fitness center available) | Spa services on site; massages and treatments available by reservation |
| Known for | Weddings, historic architecture, interior courtyard and event spaces | Magazine Street location, boutique luxury, accessible features |
| Accessibility & parking | Valet parking only; specific accessibility details not published | Multiple wheelchair-accessible features and free self parking (2 accessible spaces noted) |
| Family policy | Family-welcoming; up to 3 children 17 and under stay free in existing bedding | |
The Eliza Jane sits in the Central Business District a few blocks from the French Quarter and many downtown attractions.
Best for travelers who want fast access to the French Quarter and downtown attractions on foot.
Hotel Saint Vincent is on Magazine Street in the Lower Garden District, steps from local shops and restaurants.
Best for guests who prefer Magazine Street shopping and a quieter neighborhood base while still within reach of downtown.
The Eliza Jane offers a broad mix of guestrooms and suites inside historic buildings.
Room variety and historic character are the Eliza Jane’s strengths.
Hotel Saint Vincent has a smaller inventory of upscale rooms and suites.
Hotel Saint Vincent offers a compact, luxury-leaning room set with several suite options.
The Eliza Jane centers on French-Louisiana dining and a library-style lobby bar.
Ideal for travelers wanting a French-influenced dining option on property plus a quiet lobby bar.
Hotel Saint Vincent serves Mediterranean cuisine and has multiple casual beverage options.
Good choice for guests who want several on-site dining and bar options near Magazine Street.
The Eliza Jane does not have a pool and markets other property features instead.
Choose The Eliza Jane if a pool is not a priority and you like courtyard spaces and a fitness center.
Hotel Saint Vincent includes outdoor pool access and pool-accessible features.
Pick Hotel Saint Vincent if having an on-site outdoor pool matters to you.
The Eliza Jane focuses on fitness and downtown nightlife access rather than on-site spa treatments.
Good for active travelers who plan to use nearby nightlife and prefer a strong fitness offering.
Hotel Saint Vincent offers on-site spa services and quieter evening options nearby.
Better fit if you want spa treatments and a calmer evening neighborhood while still having on-site bars.

The Eliza Jane — a few blocks from the French Quarter, Canal Street and downtown attractions.

Hotel Saint Vincent — outdoor pool plus on-site spa services and massage treatments by reservation.

The Eliza Jane — multiple historic event spaces (Holbrook, Courtyard, Press Room) and wedding capacities up to 150.

Hotel Saint Vincent — steps from Magazine Street boutiques and restaurants in the Lower Garden District.
The Eliza Jane is a few blocks from the French Quarter and Canal Street; Hotel Saint Vincent is in the Lower Garden District and requires a longer walk or short streetcar/ride into the Quarter.
Hotel Saint Vincent has an outdoor pool and on-site spa services; The Eliza Jane does not have an on-site pool or a spa but offers a 24-hour fitness center.
Both accept guests of all ages, but The Eliza Jane explicitly markets family-friendly policies (up to three children 17 and under stay free in existing bedding) and is centrally located for sightseeing.
Hotel Saint Vincent lists free self parking onsite (including a small number of accessible spaces); The Eliza Jane offers valet parking only.
Explore how The Eliza Jane stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·